SME Times is powered by   
Search News
Just in:   • Biden administration forgives $4.7 billion loans to Ukraine  • Women entrepreneurs driving innovation, growth in gem & jewellery sector: Smriti Irani  • India’s export outlook brighter as manufactured goods gain share: RBI  • India’s consumer durable makers to log 11-12 pc growth in FY25  • SEBI’s proposal on SME IPOs: striking a delicate balance 
Last updated: 02 Dec, 2014  

Meeting.9.thmb.jpg Planning Commission: Time for silent burial

Planning.Commission.9.jpg
   Top Stories
» India’s export outlook brighter as manufactured goods gain share: RBI
» Private consumption driving growth in Q3 with rural India taking lead: RBI
» Indian MSMEs create about 10 crore jobs in 15 months
» Indian prefer Q-commerce for daily essentials, physical stores for high-value buying
» Embedded finance to unlock $25 bn revenue opportunity for India’s platforms by 2030
Bikky Khosla | 02 Dec, 2014

The Planning Commission is likely to be declared dead soon. Last week, the media reported that the Centre has zeroed in on the role and structure for a new body that would replace the 64-year old commission. Earlier in his Independence Day speech, PM Modi had told about this. People's suggestions were sought. And now the government is in the final stage of making announcement of a new body. The finer details, as reported, will be chalked out after discussion with state Chief Ministers this week.

There is little doubt that the plan panel has outlived its utility. The institution was set up in 1950 after India won independence with the belief that it would help meet the enormous amount of development work needed to be done across several sections of the economy. In addition, those were the days when socialism seemed triumphant. Our leaders, including Jawaharlal Nehru believed in a socialist model of economics. Many economists of the period, including P C Mahalanobis nurtured the faith in the system of state controlled economy. However, now we have come a long way from the days of government control over industry.

The commission was originally founded to play only an advisory role, but unfortunately it gradually became an economic cabinet not only for the Centre but also for the states and this, in turn, fueled Centre-states conflicts. Till 1967, this, however, failed to harm the Centre-states relation much due to one-party (Congress) rule at the Centre and in most of the states. But after 1967 elections, the scenario changed as the party was defeated in nine states and the non-Congress state governments opposed the increasing centralization. During the last two decades, we have seen the end of single-party dominion even at the Centre. It sounds more logical now to structure a new institution that can contribute to the federal structure of the nation.

Recently, Finance Minister Arun Jaitley has said that each state should be allowed to decide and plan how it intends to use the national resources. I think this is the right approach. Under the present mechanism, the plan panel monitors and regulates the Centre allocated resources to a state of which only about 10 percent is allowed to be used by the state government as it deems fit and outside the framework designed by the Centre. In addition, the requirement that the state Plans are to be approved by the planning commission is irksome for the states. These anomalies need to be fixed.

I invite your feedback.

 
Print the Page Add to Favorite
 
Share this on :
 

Please comment on this story:
 
Subject :
Message:
(Maximum 1500 characters)  Characters left 1500
Your name:
 

Thank God for The Planning Commission's burial
Paul | Thu Dec 4 13:42:33 2014
I believe this is a good decision. And we expect more from our PM since he is willing to make critical changes where necessary. I hope politicians will be paid less and with lesser privileges and pension .. so that it does not become a "career". I also think there should be a limit on the number of years anyone can sit in Parliament or in a Ministry. This will solve issues of dynamic rules


Change for Good or God?
Kumarasan J. | Thu Dec 4 07:25:50 2014
I think Modi & Co is treating India like a classroom. He & his brigade is teaching us like kids. The tone of their reactions as if India has got freedom just yesterday. Instead of getting down to stem the root, they are stuck in an " I told you" syndrome. They need to come out of this fast if they have do something in real time. Price-rise is an issue which hurts everybody. There is no time for polemics. BJP has been voted to power only because of rising prices & inaction on this by Congress govt. Mr. Modi should remember that he is PM of India & not of BJP. His team has to adhere to the existing norms of constitution while asking for its changes with consensus where ever needed. No one knows whether they will end up like Janta Party experiments of 70s. And it is said Janta Party did lot damage to the Idea of India. We are not prepared for a repeat


Planning Commission
Charitra Kumar Jain | Thu Dec 4 07:17:36 2014
Sir, we should have decentralize planning commission. Select different cities and monitor the planning and implementation from different places. One group of subjects from one place. Involve local bodies colleges intellectuals on assignment basis.


role of planning commission
charitra kumar jain | Thu Dec 4 07:08:54 2014
Sir, states are taking targets with budgetary provisions and will function. This assumption need monitoring. The state machinery will not respond to powerless body. The implementation of the schemes will show the results. We know that the state machineries including mp mla ministers ias officers babus are no committed. Their every action needs to be counter checked. In this scenario centre cannot reach in time every place. The planning commission with CAG and CBI should have mechanism to monitor the state working. Also award the states on 26 jan for their out standing governess.


PC
Anil Datta | Thu Dec 4 06:50:21 2014
It is welcomed that our prime minister have taken an initiative to restructure the planning commission but if we have the same set of people working for planning commission who were assisting the earlier commission than I think the very purpose of restructuring the commission will be defeated because the supporting staff will again come up with calculations based on their previous data bank which is not realistic. the supporting staff should be professionals in the respective fields of development who have the up-to-date knowledge of the developments going in the market to achieve the goal which will help in planning the schemes for the development of the country and when the country will develop every single person will progress.



D.K.Pathak | Wed Dec 3 15:55:49 2014
This is the need of time, is it worth to spend 100 cr for one person . what is the total expenses in 30 years , & what is the outcome ? Do we have this much Money to waist . Arun Jaitley is very much correct, I congratulate him for this nice vibrant decision .


Re-structuring Planning Commission
N B DEY | Wed Dec 3 13:07:00 2014
"Burial" word should not be used as it demonstrates disrespect to an institution instituted for good cause though it's"focus" has been diversified, arising necessity for re-structuring. The Centre has to be monitoring authority & play role of "watch dog" (regulator)facilitating States execute their own development programme but the same has to be got approved by the Centre, thereby holding control for ensuring that the plan outlays allocated for States are not misused. In short, the role has to remain the same, purpose has to be debated for States consensus with vision of next 20 years otherwise it will be like "old wine in new bottle".


Planning commission continuance
Chandramohan. | Wed Dec 3 03:20:12 2014
It is a must for the centre to allow the planning commission to continue in true letter and spirit.Then only the centre will have the control in approving or disapproving any schemes floated by the States for the welfare of the nation.Some schemes floated by the states will harm the national integration which is most needed of the hour.


Planning Commission: Time for silent burial
Anantha krishna | Tue Dec 2 23:47:50 2014
Copy methodologies of the most developed countries and consider the fact that the morality of many of the decision making people in this new type of planning commission is generally low.


one tex in india
arvind sharma | Tue Dec 2 16:11:09 2014
  I want one tax in all over India that goods price is same


 
  Customs Exchange Rates
Currency Import Export
US Dollar
84.35
82.60
UK Pound
106.35
102.90
Euro
92.50
89.35
Japanese Yen 55.05 53.40
As on 12 Oct, 2024
  Daily Poll
Will the new MSME credit assessment model simplify financing?
 Yes
 No
 Can't say
  Commented Stories
 
 
About Us  |   Advertise with Us  
  Useful Links  |   Terms and Conditions  |   Disclaimer  |   Contact Us  
Follow Us : Facebook Twitter